Medicare Supplement

Try to understand 10 different plans can overwhelm anyone. The most effective way to help you choose is to simplify the 10 choices into 3 “Life Styles” and then apply a few key selection criteria.
Since you are in California, where medical costs and premiums can be higher, this “category” approach works best.

Step 1: Group the 10 Plans into 3 “Buckets”

Instead of discussing Plans A, B, C, D, F, G, K, L, M, and N one by one, group them by how you feel to the your wallet:

The “Peace of Mind” Plans (Plan G):

• The Vibe: “I want to pay one premium and never see another medical bill.”
• The Reality: Plan G is the most popular for new seniors. After the Part B deductible ($283 in 2026), it covers 100% of everything else.
• Note: Plans C and F are only for those eligible for Medicare before 2020.

The “Budget-Balanced” Plans (Plan N):

• The Vibe: “I don’t mind a small copay if it keeps my monthly premium lower.”
• The Reality: Similar to Plan G, but the user pays up to $20 for doctor visits and $50 for ER visits. It also doesn’t cover “Excess Charges” (rare in CA, but something to mention).

The “Safety Net” Plans (High-Deductible G, Plan K/L):

• The Vibe: “I am healthy and want the lowest premium possible, but I want protection if something catastrophic happens.”
• The Reality: High-Deductible Plan G has a deductible of $2,950 (2026). Users pay out-of-pocket until that limit is hit, then it pays 100%.

Step 2: The 4 Selection Criteria

What will be your answer to these four questions:

Usage Frequency: “How often do you see a doctor?”

• High usage: Go with Plan G to avoid constant copays.
  • Low usage: Plan N or High-Deductible G can save hundreds in annual premiums.

Budget Predictability: “Do you prefer a higher monthly bill with no surprises, or a lower bill with occasional costs?”

• This is the classic “Premium vs. Out-of-Pocket” trade-off.

Financial Reserve: “If you had a major surgery tomorrow, could you comfortably pay a $3,000 deductible?”

• If yes, High-Deductible G is a great money-saver. If no, stick to Plan G.

Household Discount: “Are you and your spouse both signing up?”

• Many carriers offer 5%–15% discounts if two people in the same house have a policy with them.

Step 3: What You Really Need to Know (The “Gaps”)

It’s vital to clarify that no Medigap plan covers everything. Make sure they know they still need to look at:

• Prescription Drugs (Part D): Medigap does not include drugs.
• The “Big Three”: Dental, Vision, and Hearing are generally not covered by Medigap.
• The Doctor: They can see any doctor in the USA who accepts Medicare. There are no “networks” like an HMO.

Here is a clear, “yes-or-no” Decision Tree structure designed for seniors choosing a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plan. This is perfect for a Resource Library page on your SF Bay Area insurance website.
You can create this on your site using an infographic, a simple list-based interactive form (if your website plugin allows it), or a static image.

Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Plan Decision Tree
START HERE:

Are you newly eligible for Medicare (turned 65 on or after January 1, 2020)?

• [YES] → Go to Question 1
• [NO] (Eligibility started BEFORE 2020) → Go to Question F

For “New-to-Medicare” (Post-2020)

Question 1:
Do you prefer a predictable monthly cost, even if it’s higher, with almost no medical bills for Medicare-covered services?

• [YES] → Go to Question 2
• [NO] → Go to Question 3

Question 2:
Do you want a plan that covers 100% of your Medicare-approved medical costs after you meet the small annual Part B deductible (e.g., $283 in 2026)?

• [YES] → RECOMMENDATION: PLAN G
  • Best for: Ultimate peace of mind.
• [NO, I’M OKAY WITH COPAYS] → Go to Question 3

Question 3:
Are you looking for a lower premium and don’t mind paying small copays (like $20 for a doctor visit)?

• [YES] → RECOMMENDATION: PLAN N
  • Best for: A balance of low monthly cost and excellent coverage.
• [NO, I WANT EVEN LOWER PREMIUMS] → Go to Question 4

Question 4:
Are you in very good health and looking for a “safety net” plan with the lowest premium, but are willing to pay a much higher deductible ($2,950 in 2026)?

• [YES] → RECOMMENDATION: HIGH-DEDUCTIBLE PLAN G
  • Best for: Saving money if you are rarely sick.
• [NO] → (Need to re-evaluate or seek specialist advice)

For “Grandfathered” Seniors (Pre-2020)
Question F:
Do you want the plan that covers 100% of both the Part A hospital deductible AND the Part B medical deductible?

• [YES] → RECOMMENDATION: PLAN F
  • Note: Be aware that Plan F premiums are rising rapidly in California. Consider Plan G instead for better long-term value.
• [NO, I’M OKAY WITH THE PART B DEDUCTIBLE] → Go to Question 1 (Standard plans)

Need help from our guide?